Christmas Author Scavenger Hunt Stop One: The Candy Cane Secret by S.F. Baumgartner

Excerpt from the Book

She shut the door but didn’t lock it. She photographed the shipping label, both tape lines, and the box from each side.

People remembered documents differently once money got involved. And nothing stayed ordinary after somebody lied about it.

Keith had lied.

Nobody had access before the official delivery.

The mismatched forms said otherwise. The cut tape said the carton had been opened twice. Not to mention the woman by the pallet.

She pulled on the cotton gloves she kept for handling donated rare books and lifted the loose flap.

Wrapped candy canes filled the top layer. She took out each bag and set it on the floor in the order she removed it. The peppermint went sharp in the small room.

Nothing.

She checked the spaces between the bags. A machine packed the carton, but one interior flap bowed inward, and a faint line of dust stopped halfway across the cardboard, the way dust stops where paper has been sitting.

She photographed the flap.

From the sales floor came applause as the author finished a reading. That sound belonged to her ordinary life on the other side of a thin door. She could go back out to books and cookies and forget about any of this. Instead, she went through the box again.

Bottom seam. No false panel. No torn paper. Nothing to explain why anybody would log a shipment early, open it, seal it, and open it again.

She started putting the bags back.

The third one wouldn’t settle flat.

She set the bag aside and pressed the cardboard underneath. A corner rose near the sidewall.

She slid two fingers beneath the inner flap and drew out an envelope.

The paper had yellowed to the color of weak tea. One edge was soft. A dark stain marked the lower corner. Her own name was on the front in block capitals, pressed hard enough to leave grooves.

MAE

No return address.

The noise beyond the door went away from her.

She set the envelope on the desk and photographed it before she touched the flap. The seal was already broken.

That could’ve been age or Keith or the woman.

Mae opened it.

A small brass key slid into her gloved palm, a paper tag on the ring, its surface rubbed thin at the edges. Behind the key, two more things had been pressed flat against the paper.

A photograph, curled at one corner. And a strip of film in a paper sleeve.

She didn’t look at either one. She was aware of that decision and of the fact that she had never once in her career avoided reading a document.

She turned the tag toward the desk lamp.

Stamped across it, in a mark the credit union had stopped using before Kylie was born:

PGCU-17

Want to know more about the book?

A candy cane shipment. A decades-old photograph. A Christmas secret someone will do anything to keep buried.

Retired attorney and bookshop owner Mae Cassidy Reeves expects Pine Grove’s Christmas Market to bring author signings, gift wrapping, and the usual small-town bustle. Instead, a tampered candy cane delivery leaves her with an envelope addressed to her, an old photograph, and a mysterious brass key.

With former intelligence officer Cyrus Jagers and his watchful German shepherd at her side, Mae follows the clues to a beloved charity and some of Pine Grove’s most respected citizens. Their carefully worded answers point back to a Christmas Eve hit-and-run—and records someone has gone to considerable trouble to hide.

Then security footage reveals a woman who bears an unsettling resemblance to Mae’s sister-in-law, missing and presumed dead for twenty-five years.

As witnesses retreat behind polite denials and evidence goes missing, Mae must discover who is still protecting the old crime. But in a town where she knows almost everyone, recognizing a familiar face is no guarantee she knows whom to trust.

The Candy Cane Secret begins the Pine Grove Christmas Mysteries, a clean mystery series featuring small-town warmth, family secrets, gentle wit, and suspense under the Christmas lights.

Get your copy here!

About the Author

S.F. Baumgartner writes Christian suspense thrillers and clean mysteries featuring complicated families, determined investigators, and secrets that refuse to stay buried. Her books include the Mirror Estate and KC & Orlando Prime series, along with the Pine Grove Christmas Mysteries. Fatal Invitation won a 2026 Readers’ Favorite Gold Medal in Fiction–Thriller–Conspiracy, and Shadowed Secret earned a 2025 Bronze Medal in Christian–Thriller. Her novel Living Secrets was also named a 2024 Killer Nashville Top Pick in Thriller. When she isn’t plotting trouble for her characters, she enjoys crime shows such as NCIS and spending time with her cats.

Scavenger Hunt Word One: Christmas

Find the other stops here!

Giveaway!

Don’t forget to enter the giveaway for your chance to win a $50 Amazon gift card!

https://www.celebratelit.com/2027-christmas-scavenger-hunt-giveaway/